Paul,
W2 yourself does not eliminate the problem suffered by Self-Employed individuals. As a RE for more than 15 years I can assure you any credible lender will still require to see the 1040's and see the adjusted gross income. If you write off alot of items you can still have a negative adjusted gross, thus W2 is far from a solution.
Also, how do you know she will be at 70% LTV? What lender do you know will use the appraised value instead of the purchase price? Only time I have seen this done in 15 years is when the house appraises for LESS than the purchase price, NOT more.
I think you're being just a little hard on Paul. His expertise is in Real Estate matters and yes he was mistaken in this case but if you read these boards you will find he is right way more often than he is wrong.